Overview

United Kingdom

United Kingdom's overall score on the DataGovHub metric

0

United Kingdom

General Performance

CountryRegionIncome categorytotalStrategicRegulatoryResponsibleStructuralParticipatoryInternational
United KingdomEurope & Central Asia1 - High income89.17100.0080.00100.0080.0075.00100.00
GermanyEurope & Central Asia1 - High income84.1775.00100.0050.0080.00100.00100.00
AustraliaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income84.1775.0080.0075.00100.00100.0075.00
NetherlandsEurope & Central Asia1 - High income80.8375.0080.0050.0080.00100.00100.00
FranceEurope & Central Asia1 - High income79.1775.00100.0025.00100.0075.00100.00
New ZealandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income78.33100.0040.0075.0080.00100.0075.00
South KoreaEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income72.5075.0060.0025.00100.00100.0075.00
BrazilLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income70.8350.00100.0025.00100.00100.0050.00
IrelandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income70.8350.00100.0025.00100.0050.00100.00
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1 -68.33100.00100.0025.0060.00100.0025.00
FinlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income68.3375.00100.0025.0060.0050.00100.00
SwedenEurope & Central Asia1 - High income67.5050.0080.0025.00100.0050.00100.00
JapanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income65.00100.0060.0025.0080.0075.0050.00
EstoniaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income63.3350.0080.0025.00100.0050.0075.00
CanadaNorth America1 - High income63.3350.0040.0075.0040.00100.0075.00
SwitzerlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income63.3350.0080.000.00100.0075.0075.00
NorwayEurope & Central Asia1 - High income60.0075.0080.0025.0080.0050.0050.00
United StatesNorth America1 - High income57.5075.0040.0025.0080.0050.0075.00
UruguayLatin America & Caribbean1 - High income53.3350.0060.0050.0060.0050.0050.00
ChinaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income53.3375.0080.0025.0040.0075.0025.00
SingaporeEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income53.3375.0040.0025.0080.0075.0025.00
HungaryEurope & Central Asia1 - High income48.3325.0080.000.0060.0050.0075.00
IsraelMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income48.3350.0060.000.0080.0050.0050.00
ArgentinaLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income45.000.0040.000.0080.0075.0075.00
PhilippinesEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income40.8350.0060.000.0060.0050.0025.00
UkraineEurope & Central Asia3 - Lower middle income40.0025.0060.000.0080.0025.0050.00
TurkeyEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income40.0025.0060.000.0080.0050.0025.00
MexicoLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income36.6725.0060.000.0060.000.0075.00
RussiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income36.6750.0060.000.0060.0025.0025.00
South AfricaSub-Saharan Africa2 - Upper middle income35.830.0060.000.0080.0050.0025.00
IndonesiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income34.1750.0020.000.0060.0025.0050.00
ThailandEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income32.5025.0060.0025.0060.000.0025.00
KenyaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income32.5025.0080.000.0040.0025.0025.00
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income30.0075.000.000.0080.0025.000.00
ChileLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income30.000.0060.000.0020.0025.0075.00
JordanMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income30.0025.0020.000.0060.0050.0025.00
MalaysiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income30.000.000.000.0080.0075.0025.00
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income30.000.0040.000.0040.0050.0050.00
VietnamEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income30.0050.0020.000.0060.0025.0025.00
TaiwanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income29.1750.0060.000.0040.0025.000.00
GeorgiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income27.500.0060.000.0080.000.0025.00
IndiaSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income26.6725.0020.0025.0040.0050.000.00
NigeriaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income25.830.0020.000.0060.0050.0025.00
MoroccoMiddle East & North Africa3 - Lower middle income24.170.0060.000.0060.000.0025.00
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income19.1750.000.000.0040.0025.000.00
AzerbaijanEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income13.330.0040.000.0040.000.000.00
PakistanSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income11.670.0020.000.000.0050.000.00
UgandaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income10.000.0060.000.000.000.000.00
BoliviaLatin America & Caribbean3 - Lower middle income10.000.0020.000.0040.000.000.00
BangladeshSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income7.5025.0020.000.000.000.000.00
EthiopiaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income7.500.0020.000.000.0025.000.00
IranMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income3.330.0020.000.000.000.000.00

CountryRegionIncome categorytotalStrategicRegulatoryResponsibleStructuralParticipatoryInternational
United KingdomEurope & Central AsiaHigh income89.17100801008075100
GermanyEurope & Central AsiaHigh income84.17751005080100100
AustraliaEast Asia & PacificHigh income84.1775807510010075
NetherlandsEurope & Central AsiaHigh income80.8375805080100100
FranceEurope & Central AsiaHigh income79.17751002510075100
New ZealandEast Asia & PacificHigh income78.3310040758010075
South KoreaEast Asia & PacificHigh income72.5075602510010075
IrelandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income70.83501002510050100
BrazilLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income70.83501002510010050
FinlandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income68.3375100256050100
SwedenEurope & Central AsiaHigh income67.5050802510050100
European UnionEurope & Central Asia65.00100100254010025
JapanEast Asia & PacificHigh income65.001006025807550
EstoniaEurope & Central AsiaHigh income63.335080251005075
CanadaNorth AmericaHigh income63.335040754010075
SwitzerlandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income63.3350801007575
NorwayEurope & Central AsiaHigh income60.00758025805050
United StatesNorth AmericaHigh income57.50754025805075
UruguayLatin America & CaribbeanHigh income53.33506050605050
SingaporeEast Asia & PacificHigh income53.33754025807525
ChinaEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income53.33758025407525
HungaryEurope & Central AsiaHigh income48.332580605075
IsraelMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income48.335060805050
ArgentinaLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income45.0040807575
PhilippinesEast Asia & PacificLower middle income40.835060605025
TurkeyEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income40.002560805025
UkraineEurope & Central AsiaLower middle income40.002560802550
MexicoLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income36.6725606075
RussiaEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income36.675060602525
South AfricaSub-Saharan AfricaUpper middle income35.8360805025
IndonesiaEast Asia & PacificLower middle income34.175020602550
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income33.3375208025
ThailandEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income32.502560256025
KenyaSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income32.502580402525
ChileLatin America & CaribbeanHigh income30.0060202575
JordanMiddle East & North AfricaUpper middle income30.002520605025
MalaysiaEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income30.00807525
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income30.0040405050
VietnamEast Asia & PacificLower middle income30.005020602525
NigeriaSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income30.0020607525
TaiwanEast Asia & PacificHigh income29.1750604025
GeorgiaEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income27.50608025
IndiaSouth AsiaLower middle income26.672520254050
MoroccoMiddle East & North AfricaLower middle income24.17606025
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income19.17504025
AzerbaijanEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income13.334040
PakistanSouth AsiaLower middle income11.672050
BoliviaLatin America & CaribbeanLower middle income10.002040
UgandaSub-Saharan AfricaLow income10.0060
BangladeshSouth AsiaLower middle income7.502520
EthiopiaSub-Saharan AfricaLow income7.502025
IranMiddle East & North AfricaLower middle income3.3320

Region

Europe &
Central Asia

Income Category

High
Income

Strategic
100

United Kingdom

Strategic Performance

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 1 ScoreData strategyPublic administration data strategyNational guidelines for private sector data sharingAI strategy
United KingdomEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
GermanyEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
AustraliaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
NetherlandsEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
FranceEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
New ZealandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
South KoreaEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income75111
BrazilLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income5011
IrelandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1 -1001111
FinlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
SwedenEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
JapanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income1001111
EstoniaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
CanadaNorth America1 - High income5011
SwitzerlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
NorwayEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
United StatesNorth America1 - High income75111
UruguayLatin America & Caribbean1 - High income5011
ChinaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income75111
SingaporeEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income75111
HungaryEurope & Central Asia1 - High income251
IsraelMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income5011
ArgentinaLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income
PhilippinesEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income5011
UkraineEurope & Central Asia3 - Lower middle income251
TurkeyEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income251
MexicoLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income251
RussiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income5011
South AfricaSub-Saharan Africa2 - Upper middle income
IndonesiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income5011
ThailandEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
KenyaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income251
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income75111
ChileLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income
JordanMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income251
MalaysiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income
VietnamEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income5011
TaiwanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income5011
GeorgiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
IndiaSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income251
NigeriaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income
MoroccoMiddle East & North Africa3 - Lower middle income
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income5011
AzerbaijanEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
PakistanSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
UgandaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
BoliviaLatin America & Caribbean3 - Lower middle income
BangladeshSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income251
EthiopiaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
IranMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 1 ScoreData strategyPublic administration data strategyNational guidelines for private sector data sharingAI strategy
United KingdomEurope & Central AsiaHigh income1001111
GermanyEurope & Central AsiaHigh income75111
AustraliaEast Asia & PacificHigh income75111
NetherlandsEurope & Central AsiaHigh income75111
FranceEurope & Central AsiaHigh income75111
New ZealandEast Asia & PacificHigh income1001111
South KoreaEast Asia & PacificHigh income75111
IrelandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income5011
BrazilLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income5011
FinlandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income75111
SwedenEurope & Central AsiaHigh income5011
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1001111
JapanEast Asia & PacificHigh income1001111
EstoniaEurope & Central AsiaHigh income5011
CanadaNorth AmericaHigh income5011
SwitzerlandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income5011
NorwayEurope & Central AsiaHigh income75111
United StatesNorth AmericaHigh income75111
UruguayLatin America & CaribbeanHigh income5011
SingaporeEast Asia & PacificHigh income75111
ChinaEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income75111
HungaryEurope & Central AsiaHigh income251
IsraelMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income5011
ArgentinaLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income
PhilippinesEast Asia & PacificLower middle income5011
TurkeyEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income251
UkraineEurope & Central AsiaLower middle income251
MexicoLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income251
RussiaEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income5011
South AfricaSub-Saharan AfricaUpper middle income
IndonesiaEast Asia & PacificLower middle income5011
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income75111
ThailandEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income251
KenyaSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income251
ChileLatin America & CaribbeanHigh income
JordanMiddle East & North AfricaUpper middle income251
MalaysiaEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income
VietnamEast Asia & PacificLower middle income5011
NigeriaSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income
TaiwanEast Asia & PacificHigh income5011
GeorgiaEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income
IndiaSouth AsiaLower middle income251
MoroccoMiddle East & North AfricaLower middle income
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income5011
AzerbaijanEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income
PakistanSouth AsiaLower middle income
BoliviaLatin America & CaribbeanLower middle income
UgandaSub-Saharan AfricaLow income
BangladeshSouth AsiaLower middle income251
EthiopiaSub-Saharan AfricaLow income
IranMiddle East & North AfricaLower middle income

CountryData Strategy1a Data strategy sourcePublic administration data strategyPublic administration data strategy sourceNational guidelines for private sector data sharingNational guidelines for private sector data sharing sourceAI StrategyAI Strategy Source
Argentina
Australia1The Data Strategy 2021-202511
Azerbaijan
Bangladesh1National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence 2019-2024
Bolivia
Brazil11Artificial Intelligence Strategy
Canada11Pan-Canadian Artificial Intelligence Strategy (2017)
Chile
China111
Côte d’Ivoire
Estonia11
Ethiopia
European Union11European Interoperability Framework 20171Guidance on sharing private sector data in the European data economy 20181
Finland1A Finnish Model for the Secure and Effective Use of Data 20191Information Management in Public Administration Act 20191
France111For a Meaningful Artificial Intelligence: Towards a French and European Strategy (2018)
Georgia
Germany1Data Strategy of the German Federal Government 20211Data Strategy of the German Federal Government 2021(Implementation Strategy)1AI Strategy 2020
Hungary1Artificial Intelligence Strategy 2020-2030
IndiaUnlocking Value from Data and AI: The India Opportunity 20201National AI Strategy (2018)
Indonesia1One-Data Policy 20191
Iran
Ireland11AI - Here for Good 2020
Israel1The National Digital Program of the Government of Israel 201715 Year National AI Plan 2020
Japan1 2021 Data Strategy
データ戦略タスクフォース(第4回) 議事次第
1Base Registry Roadmap1Contract Guidance on the Utilization of AI and Data 20181
Jordan1Jordan Artificial Intelligence Policy 2020
Kenya1The Distributed Ledgers Technology and Artificial Intelligence Taskforce 2018
Malaysia
Mexico1
Morocco
Netherlands1NL Digitaal Data Agenda Government 20191Dutch Vision on Data Sharing between Businesses 20191Strategic Action Plan for Artificial Intelligence 2019
New Zealand1Data Strategy and Roadmap 20181Data Strategy and Roadmap for New Zealand 20181A Path to Social Licence Guidelines for Trusted Data Use1Artificial Intelligence 2018
Nigeria
Norway11National Strategy for Artifical Intelligence 2020 - Section on private sector data sharing guidelines1National Strategy for Artificial Intelligence 2020
Pakistan
Philippines1Data Sharing Agreements 20201National Artificial Intelligence Roadmap 2021
Russia1National Data Management System Uniform Requirements for the Governance of State Data1National Strategy for the Development of Artificial Intelligence 2019
Saudi Arabia1National Strategy for Data & AI 202011National Strategy for Data & AI 2020
Singapore11Singapore GUIDE TO DATA SHARING1National Artificial Intelligence Strategy 2019
South Africa
South Korea1Korea Digital New Deal11
Sweden1Final Report: Assignment to increase the public administration's ability to make open data available, pursue open and data-driven innovation and use artificial intelligence1National approach to artificial intelligence 2018
Switzerland1Digital Switzerland Strategy Objective 7: Data, digital content and artificial intelligence1Artificial Intelligence 2018
Taiwan1Digital Government Program 2.0 of Taiwan 2021-20251Taiwan AI Action Plan
Thailand1Thailand 4.0 Plan 2015
Data Governance Framework
Turkey1National Artificial Intelligence Strategy 2021-2025
Uganda
Ukraine1Concept for the Development of AI 2020
United Arab Emirates11UAE Strategy for Artificial Intelligence 2017
United Kingdom1UK National Data Strategy (2020)1UK National Data Strategy 20201UK Data sharing: a code of practice1
United States1The Federal Big Data Research and Development Strategic Plan (2016)11
Uruguay11Artificial Intelligence Strategy for Digital Government 2019
Vietnam11National strategy on research, development and application of artificial intelligence

Regulatory
80

United Kingdom

Regulatory Performance

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 2 ScoreLaw for the protection of personal dataOpen data law for the proactive release of government information by defaultFreedom of Information Act ensuring citizens can access government documentsRight to be protected from automated decision-makingRight to data portability
United KingdomEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
GermanyEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
AustraliaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
NetherlandsEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
FranceEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
New ZealandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income4011
South KoreaEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income60111
BrazilLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income10011111
IrelandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1 -10011111
FinlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
SwedenEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
JapanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income60111
EstoniaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
CanadaNorth America1 - High income4011
SwitzerlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
NorwayEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
United StatesNorth America1 - High income4011
UruguayLatin America & Caribbean1 - High income60111
ChinaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income801111
SingaporeEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income4011
HungaryEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
IsraelMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income60111
ArgentinaLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income4011
PhilippinesEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income60111
UkraineEurope & Central Asia3 - Lower middle income60111
TurkeyEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income60111
MexicoLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income60111
RussiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income60111
South AfricaSub-Saharan Africa2 - Upper middle income60111
IndonesiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income201
ThailandEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income60111
KenyaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income801111
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income
ChileLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income60111
JordanMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income201
MalaysiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income4011
VietnamEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income201
TaiwanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income60111
GeorgiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income60111
IndiaSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income201
NigeriaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income201
MoroccoMiddle East & North Africa3 - Lower middle income60111
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income
AzerbaijanEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income4011
PakistanSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income201
UgandaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income60111
BoliviaLatin America & Caribbean3 - Lower middle income201
BangladeshSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income201
EthiopiaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income201
IranMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income201

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 2 ScoreLaw for the protection of personal dataOpen data law for the proactive release of government information by defaultFreedom of Information Act ensuring citizens can access government documentsRight to be protected from automated decision-makingRight to data portability
United KingdomEurope & Central AsiaHigh income801111
GermanyEurope & Central AsiaHigh income10011111
AustraliaEast Asia & PacificHigh income801111
NetherlandsEurope & Central AsiaHigh income801111
FranceEurope & Central AsiaHigh income10011111
New ZealandEast Asia & PacificHigh income4011
South KoreaEast Asia & PacificHigh income60111
IrelandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income10011111
BrazilLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income10011111
FinlandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income10011111
SwedenEurope & Central AsiaHigh income801111
European UnionEurope & Central Asia10011111
JapanEast Asia & PacificHigh income60111
EstoniaEurope & Central AsiaHigh income801111
CanadaNorth AmericaHigh income4011
SwitzerlandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income801111
NorwayEurope & Central AsiaHigh income801111
United StatesNorth AmericaHigh income4011
UruguayLatin America & CaribbeanHigh income60111
SingaporeEast Asia & PacificHigh income4011
ChinaEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income801111
HungaryEurope & Central AsiaHigh income801111
IsraelMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income60111
ArgentinaLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income4011
PhilippinesEast Asia & PacificLower middle income60111
TurkeyEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income60111
UkraineEurope & Central AsiaLower middle income60111
MexicoLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income60111
RussiaEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income60111
South AfricaSub-Saharan AfricaUpper middle income60111
IndonesiaEast Asia & PacificLower middle income201
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income201
ThailandEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income60111
KenyaSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income801111
ChileLatin America & CaribbeanHigh income60111
JordanMiddle East & North AfricaUpper middle income201
MalaysiaEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income4011
VietnamEast Asia & PacificLower middle income201
NigeriaSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income201
TaiwanEast Asia & PacificHigh income60111
GeorgiaEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income60111
IndiaSouth AsiaLower middle income201
MoroccoMiddle East & North AfricaLower middle income60111
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income
AzerbaijanEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income4011
PakistanSouth AsiaLower middle income201
BoliviaLatin America & CaribbeanLower middle income201
UgandaSub-Saharan AfricaLow income60111
BangladeshSouth AsiaLower middle income201
EthiopiaSub-Saharan AfricaLow income201
IranMiddle East & North AfricaLower middle income201

Country2a Law for the protection of personal data
2a Law for the protection of personal data source2b Open data law for the proactive release of government information by default2b Open data law for the proactive release of government information by default source2c Freedom of Information Act ensuring citizens can access government documents2c Freedom of Information Act ensuring citizens can access government documents source2d Right to be protected from automated decision-making2d Right to be protected from automated decision-making source2e Right to data portability2e Right to data portability source
Argentina11
Australia1111
Azerbaijan11
Bangladesh1
Bolivia1
Brazil11111
Canada11
Chile111
China1111
Côte d’Ivoire11
Estonia111PDPA § 21. Automatic processing
1GDPR
Ethiopia1
European Union11111
Finland1111GDPR1GDPR
France1Law 78-17 (The Data Protection Act, DPA)
Decree 2019-536 (The Implementing Decree)
Law 2016-321 (Law for a Digital Republic)
111DPA Article 471DPA Article 55 confirms the applicability of Art 20

Law for a Digital Republic, Title II, Chapter 1, Section 2 enhances these rights
Georgia111
Germany1111BDSG Section 371GDPR
Hungary1111
India1
Indonesia1
Iran1
Ireland1111DPA Article 571GDPR
Israel1Protection of Privacy Law, 5741-198111Freedom of Information Law, 5758-1998
Japan111
Jordan1
Kenya1Data Protection Act No. 24 of 2019111
Malaysia
Mexico111
Morocco111
Netherlands1111GDPR
New Zealand11
Nigeria1
Norway1111
Pakistan1
Philippines1Republic Act 10173 – Data Privacy Act of 201211
Russia111
Saudi Arabia1
Singapore11
South Africa111
  • Protection of Personal Information Act, 2013
South Korea111
Sweden111GDPR1GDPR
Switzerland1111
Taiwan111
Thailand111
Turkey111
Uganda111
Ukraine111
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom1111
United States11
Uruguay111
Vietnam1

Responsible
100

United Kingdom

Responsible Performance

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 3 ScoreDigital charterPublic sector data ethics frameworkAI ethics frameworkTrust framework for digital identity management
United KingdomEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
GermanyEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
AustraliaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
NetherlandsEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
FranceEurope & Central Asia1 - High income251
New ZealandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
South KoreaEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income251
BrazilLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income251
IrelandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income251
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1 -251
FinlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income251
SwedenEurope & Central Asia1 - High income251
JapanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income251
EstoniaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income251
CanadaNorth America1 - High income75111
SwitzerlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income
NorwayEurope & Central Asia1 - High income251
United StatesNorth America1 - High income251
UruguayLatin America & Caribbean1 - High income5011
ChinaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
SingaporeEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income251
HungaryEurope & Central Asia1 - High income
IsraelMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income
ArgentinaLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income
PhilippinesEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income
UkraineEurope & Central Asia3 - Lower middle income
TurkeyEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
MexicoLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income
RussiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
South AfricaSub-Saharan Africa2 - Upper middle income
IndonesiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income
ThailandEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
KenyaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income
ChileLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income
JordanMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income
MalaysiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income
VietnamEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income
TaiwanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income
GeorgiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
IndiaSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income251
NigeriaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income
MoroccoMiddle East & North Africa3 - Lower middle income
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income
AzerbaijanEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
PakistanSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
UgandaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
BoliviaLatin America & Caribbean3 - Lower middle income
BangladeshSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
EthiopiaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
IranMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 3 ScoreDigital charterPublic sector data ethics frameworkAI ethics frameworkTrust framework for digital identity management
United KingdomEurope & Central AsiaHigh income1001111
GermanyEurope & Central AsiaHigh income5011
AustraliaEast Asia & PacificHigh income75111
NetherlandsEurope & Central AsiaHigh income5011
FranceEurope & Central AsiaHigh income251
New ZealandEast Asia & PacificHigh income75111
South KoreaEast Asia & PacificHigh income251
IrelandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income251
BrazilLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income251
FinlandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income251
SwedenEurope & Central AsiaHigh income251
European UnionEurope & Central Asia251
JapanEast Asia & PacificHigh income251
EstoniaEurope & Central AsiaHigh income251
CanadaNorth AmericaHigh income75111
SwitzerlandEurope & Central AsiaHigh income
NorwayEurope & Central AsiaHigh income251
United StatesNorth AmericaHigh income251
UruguayLatin America & CaribbeanHigh income5011
SingaporeEast Asia & PacificHigh income251
ChinaEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income251
HungaryEurope & Central AsiaHigh income
IsraelMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income
ArgentinaLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income
PhilippinesEast Asia & PacificLower middle income
TurkeyEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income
UkraineEurope & Central AsiaLower middle income
MexicoLatin America & CaribbeanUpper middle income
RussiaEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income
South AfricaSub-Saharan AfricaUpper middle income
IndonesiaEast Asia & PacificLower middle income
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income
ThailandEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income251
KenyaSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income
ChileLatin America & CaribbeanHigh income
JordanMiddle East & North AfricaUpper middle income
MalaysiaEast Asia & PacificUpper middle income
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income
VietnamEast Asia & PacificLower middle income
NigeriaSub-Saharan AfricaLower middle income
TaiwanEast Asia & PacificHigh income
GeorgiaEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income
IndiaSouth AsiaLower middle income251
MoroccoMiddle East & North AfricaLower middle income
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North AfricaHigh income
AzerbaijanEurope & Central AsiaUpper middle income
PakistanSouth AsiaLower middle income
BoliviaLatin America & CaribbeanLower middle income
UgandaSub-Saharan AfricaLow income
BangladeshSouth AsiaLower middle income
EthiopiaSub-Saharan AfricaLow income
IranMiddle East & North AfricaLower middle income

Country3a Digital charter3a Digital charter source3b Public sector data ethics framework3b Public sector data ethics framework source3c AI ethics framework3c AI ethics framework source3d Trust framework for digital identity management3d Trust framework for digital identity management source
Argentina
Australia1Public Sector Data Management1Australia’s Artificial Intelligence Ethics Framework1Trusted Digital Identity Framework Release
Azerbaijan
Bangladesh
Bolivia
Brazil1Civil Rights Framework for the Internet
Canada1Canada Digital Charter11Pan-Canadian Trust Framework Overview
Chile
China1
Côte d’Ivoire
Estonia1Everyone's rights in the e-state
Ethiopia
European Union 1
Finland1
France1How can humans keep the upper hand? Report on the ethical matters raised by algorithms and artificial intelligence
Georgia
Germany1Opinion of the Data Ethics Commission1ETHICS COMMISSION AUTOMATED AND CONNECTED DRIVING REPORT (EXTRACT)
Hungary
India1Approach Document for India Part 1 – Principles for Responsible AI
Indonesia
Iran
Ireland1Data Sharing and Governance Act 2019
Israel
Japan1Social Principles of Human-Centric AI
Jordan
Kenya
Malaysia
Mexico
Morocco
Netherlands11
New Zealand11Trustworthy AI in Aotearoa AI Principles1Progressing Digital Identity: Establishing a Trust Framework
Nigeria
Norway1
Pakistan
Philippines
Russia
Saudi Arabia
Singapore1
South Africa
South Korea1
Sweden1New Technology Testing for Automation within Public Administration
Switzerland
Taiwan
Thailand1Digital Thailand AI Ethics Principles and Guidelines
Turkey
Uganda
Ukraine
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom1UK Digital Charter11Artificial Intelligence: How to get it right1The UK digital identity and attributes trust framework
United States1
Uruguay1Rights of digital citizenship1Artificial Intelligence Strategy for Digital Government
Vietnam

Structural
80

United Kingdom

Structural Performance

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 4 ScoreData protection bodyOpen data portalOpen data bodyPublic sector data governance bodyInternational data affairs body
United KingdomEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
GermanyEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
AustraliaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
NetherlandsEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
FranceEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
New ZealandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
South KoreaEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income10011111
BrazilLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income10011111
IrelandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1 -60111
FinlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income60111
SwedenEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
JapanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income801111
EstoniaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
CanadaNorth America1 - High income4011
SwitzerlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
NorwayEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
United StatesNorth America1 - High income801111
UruguayLatin America & Caribbean1 - High income60111
ChinaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income4011
SingaporeEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income801111
HungaryEurope & Central Asia1 - High income60111
IsraelMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income801111
ArgentinaLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income801111
PhilippinesEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income60111
UkraineEurope & Central Asia3 - Lower middle income801111
TurkeyEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income801111
MexicoLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income60111
RussiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income60111
South AfricaSub-Saharan Africa2 - Upper middle income801111
IndonesiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income60111
ThailandEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income60111
KenyaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income4011
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income801111
ChileLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income201
JordanMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income60111
MalaysiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income801111
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income4011
VietnamEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income60111
TaiwanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income4011
GeorgiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income801111
IndiaSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income4011
NigeriaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income60111
MoroccoMiddle East & North Africa3 - Lower middle income60111
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income4011
AzerbaijanEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income4011
PakistanSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
UgandaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
BoliviaLatin America & Caribbean3 - Lower middle income4011
BangladeshSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
EthiopiaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
IranMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 4 ScoreData protection bodyOpen data portalOpen data bodyPublic sector data governance bodyInternational data affairs body
United KingdomEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
GermanyEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
AustraliaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
NetherlandsEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
FranceEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
New ZealandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
South KoreaEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income10011111
BrazilLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income10011111
IrelandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1 -60111
FinlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income60111
SwedenEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
JapanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income801111
EstoniaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
CanadaNorth America1 - High income4011
SwitzerlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income10011111
NorwayEurope & Central Asia1 - High income801111
United StatesNorth America1 - High income801111
UruguayLatin America & Caribbean1 - High income60111
ChinaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income4011
SingaporeEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income801111
HungaryEurope & Central Asia1 - High income60111
IsraelMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income801111
ArgentinaLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income801111
PhilippinesEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income60111
UkraineEurope & Central Asia3 - Lower middle income801111
TurkeyEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income801111
MexicoLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income60111
RussiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income60111
South AfricaSub-Saharan Africa2 - Upper middle income801111
IndonesiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income60111
ThailandEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income60111
KenyaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income4011
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income801111
ChileLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income201
JordanMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income60111
MalaysiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income801111
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income4011
VietnamEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income60111
TaiwanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income4011
GeorgiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income801111
IndiaSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income4011
NigeriaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income60111
MoroccoMiddle East & North Africa3 - Lower middle income60111
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income4011
AzerbaijanEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income4011
PakistanSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
UgandaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
BoliviaLatin America & Caribbean3 - Lower middle income4011
BangladeshSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
EthiopiaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
IranMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income

Country4a Data protection body4a Data protection body source4b Open data portal4b Open data portal source4c Open data body4c Open data body source4d Public sector data governance body4d Public sector data governance body source4e International data affairs body4e International data affairs body source
Argentina1Agency for Access to Public Information1https://datos.gob.ar1Ministry of Public Innovation and Undersecretariat of Open Government and Digital Country1Ministry of Public Innovation and Undersecretariat of Open Government and Digital Country
Australia1Office of the Australian Information Commissioner1http://data.gov.au/111Ambassador for Cyber Affairs and Critical Technology
Azerbaijan1Ministry of Communications and Information Technologies1https://www.opendata.az/en
Bangladesh
Bolivia1Electronic Government and Information and Communication Technologies Agency (AGETIC)1Electronic Government and Information and Communication Technologies Agency (AGETIC)
Brazil1Agência Nacional de Proteção de Dados1http://dados.gov.br/1Management Committee of the National Open Data Infrastructure (INDA)11Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Canada1Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada1http://open.canada.ca/en
Chile1
China1China's key enforcement agencies1Bureau of International Cooperation
Côte d’Ivoire1Autorité de régulation des télécommunications/TIC de Cote d’Ivoire (ARTCI)1https://data.gouv.ci/
Estonia1Estonian Data Protection Inspectorate1https://avaandmed.eesti.ee/111Ambassadors-at-Large for Cyber Diplomacy and for Digital Affairs
Ethiopia
European Union1European Data Protection Board1http://open-data.europa.eu/000
Finland1Office of the Data Protection Ombudsman1https://www.avoindata.fi/en1Public Administration Information Utilization Division of the Public Administration Information Management Board -  Ministry of Finance
France1Commission Nationale de l'Informatique et des Libertés1http://data.gouv.fr/1Etalab coordinates the policy of openness and sharing of public data ( open data ) : It coordinates the actions of State administrations and provides them with support to facilitate the dissemination and reuse of their public information1Chief Technology Officer & Chief Data Officer1Ambassador for International Affairs
Georgia1State Inspector's Service1https://www.data.gov.ge/1Data Exchange Agency1Data Exchange Agency
Germany1Die Bundesbeauftragte für den Datenschutz und die Informationsfreiheit1https://www.govdata.de/1Open Data competence center acts as a contact and support center for authorities. 1Special Representative for Cyber Foreign Policy and Cyber Security
Hungary1Data Protection Commissioner of Hungary1https://kozadat.hu/kereso/1Data Assets Agency
India1http://data.gov.in/1International Cooperation Division, Ministry of Electronics and Technology
Indonesia1https://data.go.id/1 Central Level Secretariat, and Steering Committee, of One Data Indonesia1Central Level Secretariat, and Steering Committee, of One Data Indonesia
Iran
Ireland1data protection commissioner1https://data.gov.ie/1Open Data Governance Board (ODGB) under the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, as set up by the Open Data Strategy1Data Governance Unit in the Office of Government Chief Information Officer (OGCIO); Data Governance Board1EU Affairs, Digital and Access to Finance Division
Israel1Israel Privacy Protection Authority1https://info.data.gov.il/datagov/home/1Government ICT Authority1Government ICT Authority
Japan1Personal Information Protection Commission1https://www.data.go.jp/?lang=english1Japan IT General Strategy Office The Information and Communication Technology (IT) Comprehensive Strategy Office of the Cabinet Office has set up a consultation desk to receive comprehensive questions and requests regarding the utilization of public-private data, including "Questions / opinions regarding requests for disclosure of government-owned data as open data and efforts by the government for open data"1Digital Agency
Jordan1https://portal.jordan.gov.jo/wps/portal/OpenData?lang=en1Ministry of Planning and International Cooperation, Open Government Unit

Ministry of Digital Economy and Entrepenuership also plays a role
1Ministry of Digital Economy and Entrepreneurship
Kenya1Office of the Data Protection Commissioner1http://opendata.go.ke/
Malaysia1Personal Data Protection Department (PDPD)1https://www.data.gov.my/1MAMPU Digital Government office1MAMPU Digital Government office
Mexico1Instituto Nacional de Transparencia, Acceso a la Información y Protección de Datos Personales1http://datos.gob.mx/1General Head Office of Open Government and Transparency of the National Institute for Transparency, Access to Information and Personal Data Protection (INAI)
Morocco1National Control Commission for the Protection of Personal Data1http://data.gov.ma/1Open Data Steering Committee of the Digital Development Agency
Netherlands1Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens1https://data.overheid.nl/1National program for Sustainable Digital Information Management1Policy, International, Strategy and Communication Department
New Zealand1Office of the Privacy Commissioner1http://www.data.govt.nz/1Chief Data Steward1Chief Data Steward

Digital Government Partnership
Nigeria1National Information Technology Development Agency1http://www.data.gov.ng/1International Cooperation Operational Department, Ministry of Communication and Digital Economy
Norway1Norwegian Data Protection Authority1https://data.norge.no/1Directorate for Digitalisation (DIGDIR), formerly Directorate for Public Administration and ICT/Agency for Public Management and eGovernment, under the Ministry of Local Government and Modernisation1Norwegian Resource Center for Sharing of Data - DIGDIR
Pakistan
Philippines1National Privacy Commission1http://data.gov.ph/1Open Data Task Force
Open data Philippines project is operated and maintained by the Technical and Data Management teams of the National Government Portal (NGP) project of the Department of Information and Communications Technology (DICT). The policy direction of ODPH, as well as the coordination with the whole Philippine Government, is a joint effort of the members of the Open Data Task Force.
0
Russia11http://opengovdata.ru/1
Saudi Arabia1https://data.gov.sa/en1Open data and Information Access Officer (ODIAO) within the National Data Management Office11International Partnerships Department of the Saudi e-Government Program
Singapore1Personal Data Protection Commission1http://data.gov.sg/1Government Data Office1International Partnerships
South Africa1The Information Regulator1https://southafrica.opendataforafrica.org/

https://www.datafirst.uct.ac.za/dataportal/index.php/catalog
1Department of Public Service and Administration01Program 6: ICT International Affairs and Trade, Ministry of Telecommunications and Post
South Korea1Personal Information Protection Commission1http://www.data.go.kr/1Public Data Strategy Council : Open Data Strategy Council is an organization that deliberate, coordinate, monitor and evaluate government’s major Open Data policies, plans and their implementation. Public data refers to all databases, electronic files etc. that government and public sector organizations have electronically created or acquired and are managing 14th (Industrial Revolution) Committee, Data Special Committee

Korean Data Industry Promotion Agency
1International Cooperation Bureau
Sweden1Swedish Authority for Privacy Protection1https://www.dataportal.se/en1DIGG works to promote the making available and re-use of data from the public administration1DIGG1Office of International Affairs
Switzerland1Federal Data Protection and Information Commissioner1https://opendata.swiss/en1Open Government Data office based at the Federal Statistical Office (FSO) 1National Data Management NaDB Program through Federal Statistics Office- incharge of once only principle but that's it?

Digital Transformation and ICT Management (DTI) in charge of master data management system
1International Relations Division
Taiwan1https://data.gov.tw/en1Open data Action Plan 2021-2024 gives commitment 1-1, 'A complete system for opening and reusing government data,' to the Information Management Office of the National Development Commission, Division of Information Promotion

Consultant Committee for Government Open Data
Thailand1https://data.go.th/1The Digital Government Development Agency "under the name "data.go.th" at the Digital Government Development Agency. (Public Organization) or NEDA was developed under the concept of being the center of access to open government information of the country that allows people to access government information conveniently, quickly, all the time".1Foreign Affairs Division
Turkey1Kişisel Verileri Koruma Kurulu1Digital Transformation Office: Establishing and running the national Open Data Portal for sharing public data and determining the procedures, principles and standards on data transfer by public institutions to the Portal.1Department of Big data and Artificial Intelligence Applications1Department of International Relations, Presidents office of Digital Transformation
Uganda
Ukraine1Department for Personal Data Protection of the Secretariat of the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine Commissioner for Human Rights1http://data.gov.ua/1Ministry of Digital Transformation

One of the priorities of the Ministry of Digital Transformation is the development of open data in Ukraine - we are working on improving the legislation, opening new data sets, and implementing various projects together with partners
1Directorate General for Digitalization
United Arab Emirates1https://bayanat.ae/1Department of International Relations, Telecommunications and Digital Government Regulatory Authority
United Kingdom1The Information Commissioner’s Office1http://data.gov.uk/1Department of Digital, Culture, Media, and Sports (DCMS)1Data Advisory Board

DCMS
United States1Federal Trade Commission1https://www.data.gov/1CDO Council1Digital Trade Attaches
Uruguay1Unidad Reguladora de Control de Datos Personales1https://catalogodatos.gub.uy/1Data Management Division
Vietnam1https://data.gov.vn/01The Ministry of Information and Communications1Department of International Cooperation

Participatory
75

United Kingdom

Participatory Performance

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 5 ScorePublic consultation on personal data protectionPublic consultation on public dataExpert advisory body on ethicsExpert advisory body on data-driven technical change and its impact on society
United KingdomEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
GermanyEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
AustraliaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
NetherlandsEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
FranceEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
New ZealandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
South KoreaEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income1001111
BrazilLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income1001111
IrelandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1 -1001111
FinlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
SwedenEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
JapanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income75111
EstoniaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
CanadaNorth America1 - High income1001111
SwitzerlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
NorwayEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
United StatesNorth America1 - High income5011
UruguayLatin America & Caribbean1 - High income5011
ChinaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income75111
SingaporeEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income75111
HungaryEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
IsraelMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income5011
ArgentinaLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income75111
PhilippinesEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income5011
UkraineEurope & Central Asia3 - Lower middle income251
TurkeyEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income5011
MexicoLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income
RussiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income251
South AfricaSub-Saharan Africa2 - Upper middle income5011
IndonesiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
ThailandEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income
KenyaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income251
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income251
ChileLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income251
JordanMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income5011
MalaysiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income75111
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income5011
VietnamEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income251
TaiwanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income251
GeorgiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
IndiaSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income5011
NigeriaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income5011
MoroccoMiddle East & North Africa3 - Lower middle income
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income251
AzerbaijanEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
PakistanSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income5011
UgandaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
BoliviaLatin America & Caribbean3 - Lower middle income
BangladeshSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
EthiopiaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income251
IranMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 5 ScorePublic consultation on personal data protectionPublic consultation on public dataExpert advisory body on ethicsExpert advisory body on data-driven technical change and its impact on society
United KingdomEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
GermanyEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
AustraliaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
NetherlandsEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
FranceEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
New ZealandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
South KoreaEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income1001111
BrazilLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income1001111
IrelandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1 -1001111
FinlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
SwedenEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
JapanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income75111
EstoniaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
CanadaNorth America1 - High income1001111
SwitzerlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
NorwayEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
United StatesNorth America1 - High income5011
UruguayLatin America & Caribbean1 - High income5011
ChinaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income75111
SingaporeEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income75111
HungaryEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
IsraelMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income5011
ArgentinaLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income75111
PhilippinesEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income5011
UkraineEurope & Central Asia3 - Lower middle income251
TurkeyEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income5011
MexicoLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income
RussiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income251
South AfricaSub-Saharan Africa2 - Upper middle income5011
IndonesiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
ThailandEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income
KenyaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income251
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income251
ChileLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income251
JordanMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income5011
MalaysiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income75111
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income5011
VietnamEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income251
TaiwanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income251
GeorgiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
IndiaSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income5011
NigeriaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income5011
MoroccoMiddle East & North Africa3 - Lower middle income
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income251
AzerbaijanEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
PakistanSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income5011
UgandaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
BoliviaLatin America & Caribbean3 - Lower middle income
BangladeshSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
EthiopiaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income251
IranMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income

Country5a Public consultation on personal data protection5a Public consultation on personal data protection source5b Public consultation on public data5b Public consultation on public data source5c Expert advisory body on ethics5c Expert advisory body on ethics source5d Expert advisory body on data-driven technical change and its impact on society5d Expert advisory body on data-driven technical change and its impact on society sourcewidpublic consultation portal
Argentina1Although the main text governing personal data (The Personal Data Protection Act) was largely modeled after the GDPR, significant movement has been made to revise the draft after consultations with the private sector firms and NGO's. Privacy Tracker: Argentina's New Bill1Public consultation for Open Government Capacitieis in December of 2017 through the platform Consulta Publica 1National Big Data Observatory - The National Big Data Observatory was created through Resolution 11/17 and its objective is to analyze the evolution of Big Data technology in terms of possibilities for innovation, public use, technological, political, economic and social benefits within a framework sustainable.https://consultapublica.argentina.gob.ar/
Australia1Australia allows for public consultations regarding amendments, drafts or changes to their privacy law. One such consultation, for example, allowed for community members to voice their opinion on personal data collection to track COVID 19 cases. This example is linked. Consultations for Tracing Purposes1Public Data Legislation open for public consultation in 2018: Public Data Sharing Legislation Open for Consultation 11https://info.australia.gov.au/news-and-social-media/public-consultations
Azerbaijan
Bangladesh
Bolivia
Brazil1January 29, 2021, ANPD's public consultation on application of Law No. 13.709/2018, the General Law for the Protection of Personal Data, for micro and small businesses1There was a Public Consultation in association witht he Ministry of Economy's Open Data Plan. See Annex III for feedback1National Data Protection Council - The council is tasked with the formulation of guidelines for the application of the data protection rules, including the provision of subsidies for the creation of the national data protection and privacy policy. In addition to various government officials, the council includes representatives of civil society organizations, academia, trade unions and various public sector bodies.1Consultative Council and Advisory Board for Digital Transformationhttp://www4.planalto.gov.br/legislacao/consulta-publica
Canada1Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada's consultations1Modernizing Canada’s Privacy Act – Online Public Consultation1Advisory Council on Ethics and Modernization of Microdata Access - The Advisory Council on Ethics and Modernization of Microdata Access provides Statistics Canada with the appropriate guidance on data access, privacy and data governance to maintain and support the data needs of Canadians. 1Expert Advisory Group on Society, Technology, & Ethics in a Pandemic - At the request of Canada’s Chief Science Advisor, Dr. Mona Nemer, CIFAR established an Expert Advisory Group (EAG) on Society, Technology and Ethics in a Pandemic (STEP) to advise on the technical, social, legal, and ethical considerations for deploying novel technologies in response to COVID-19.https://open.canada.ca/data/en/dataset/7c03f039-3753-4093-af60-74b0f7b2385d
Chile1National Council of Innovation for Development - Chile’s National Council of Innovation for Development (CNID) is a government agency that supports and provides advice to the Presidency of Chile on STI matters,

Ten experts will work together to create a National Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy
Unsure about this one: http://nuestraconstitucion.cl/
China1On 21 October 2020, China’s top legislative body issued the draft Personal Information Protection Law (“Draft PIPL”) for public consultation. China issues draft Personal Information Protection Law for consultation
1China's Draft Data Security Law, which will come into effect on Sept. 1, 2021 was submitted for public consultation. This law concerns government release of data. China Issues Draft Data Security Law for Public Comment 1National New Generation Artificial Intelligence Governance Expert Committee,Governance Principles for a New Generation of Artificial Intelligence: Develop Responsible Artificial Intelligence (新一代人工智能治理原则——发展负责任的人工智能),http://www.most.gov.cn/kjbgz/201906/t20190617_147107.html
Côte d’Ivoire1The Open Gov. Partnership in cooperation with the government of Côte d’Ivoire is engaging in a open consultation regarding transparency in government information. Open Gov. Action Plan Open for Comments1Ethics and Moral Sub-Committee, Consultative Committee for the Protection of Personal Data, Telecommunications / ICT Regulatory Authority of Côte d'Ivoire (ARTCI)
Estonia1The European Data Protection Board held public consultations for the GDPR ended in October of 2020. EDPB Consultations for GDPR 1The European Commission held public consultations regarding publically available datasets here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12111-Open-data-availability-of-public-datasets_en https://osale.ee/

https://www.riigikantselei.ee/en/news/significant-additions-made-e-consultation-system
Ethiopia1"So far, no meaningful public consultation has been
held on the draft. The Ministry of Innovation and Technology
sought feedback in a call sent out to a mailing list in April 2020,
and those invited were asked to provide their comments in
Google Forms.152 No public consultation has been held since
then on the draft data protection law"
http://www.mom.gov.et/index.php/public-consultation/
European Union1The European Data Protection Board held public consultations for the GDPR ended in October of 2020. EDPB Consultations for GDPR 1The European Commission held public consultations regarding publically available datasets here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12111-Open-data-availability-of-public-datasets_en 1EU Ethics Advisory Group on Data - European Data Protection Supervisor decision establishing an external advisory group on the ethical dimensions of data protection (‘the Ethics Advisory Group’)

https://edps.europa.eu/data-protection/our-work/ethics_en
1
  • High-Level Expert Group on Artificial Intelligence
  • European Economic and Social Committee
  • Transport, Energy, Infrastructure and the Information Society Commission
  • Data Innovation Board
  • European COVID-19 Data Platform
https://ec.europa.eu/info/consultations_en
Finland1The European Data Protection Board held public consultations for the GDPR ended in October of 2020. EDPB Consultations for GDPR 1The European Commission held public consultations regarding publically available datasets here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12111-Open-data-availability-of-public-datasets_en https://www.otakantaa.fi/fi/
France1https://www.cnil.fr/sites/default/files/atoms/files/resultats_de_la_consultation_publique_reglement_0.pdf1The European Commission held public consultations regarding publically available datasets here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12111-Open-data-availability-of-public-datasets_en 1French National Committee for Digital Ethics - This French National Committee for Digital Ethics (FNCDE) shall “submit initial contributions on the ethics of digital sciences, technologies, uses and innovations and determine relevant equilibria for the organization of public debate on digital ethics and artificial intelligence’’. It was also given the task of raising awareness, informing and assisting individuals, companies, administrations, institutions, etc., in their decision-making process.https://www.anses.fr/en/content/public-consultations
Georgiahttps://ogpgeorgia.gov.ge/en/consultation/
Germany1The German Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BfDI) recently announced a public consultation process regarding anonymization under the European Union General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) that is intended to provide the BfDI’s position regarding the legal framework for anonymizing personal data and to solicit and evaluate public comments on the topic. The BfDI guidance resulting from the consultation will be helpful since European data protection authorities have not provided any in depth guidance regarding requirements for anonymization under the GDPR. https://www.jdsupra.com/legalnews/german-bfdi-initiates-public-81315/ 1The European Commission held public consultations regarding publically available datasets here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12111-Open-data-availability-of-public-datasets_en 1Data Ethics Commission - The task of the Federal Government’s Data Ethics Commission (“Datenethikkommission”) will be to build on scientific and technical expertise in developing ethical guidelines for the protection of the individual, the preservation of social cohesion, and the safeguarding and promotion of prosperity in the information age.1Scientific Advisory Board - Suggestions from SAB members included increasing incentives for data sharing. They also emphasised the importance of consistent semantics to ensure interoperability, plus concrete use of internationally standardised data-exchange models within the MII.

Young Digital Economy Advisory Board - The Young Digital Economy Advisory Board gives the Federal Minister for Economic Affairs and Energy first-hand advice on current issues of the digital transformation. The focus is on the development and potential of the young digital economy and new digital technologies in Germany.
https://www.bafin.de/EN/RechtRegelungen/Konsultationen/Konsultationen_node_en.html
Hungary1The European Data Protection Board held public consultations for the GDPR ended in October of 2020. EDPB Consultations for GDPR 1The European Commission held public consultations regarding publically available datasets here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12111-Open-data-availability-of-public-datasets_en
India1Draft Information Technology Rules incorporated consultations from major stakeholders such as social media companies and messaging companies. The 2018 Rules that were under consultation were designed to replace rules within the 2000 Information Technology Act (primary data governance legislation). Consultation for Draft IT Rules 1Public consultation on Government Open Data Use Licensehttps://innovate.mygov.in/dpi-public-consultation/

https://www.mca.gov.in/content/mca/global/en/econsultation.html
Indonesia1Public Consultation on Draft Regulation of the Minister of Communication and Informatics Regarding Data Interoperability
Iran
Ireland1The European Data Protection Board held public consultations for the GDPR ended in October of 2020. EDPB Consultations for GDPR 1Country specific: Ireland held an open consultation for their draft Open Data Strategy found here.https://www.gov.ie/en/consultations/
Israel1The Ministry of Justice is currently examining how and in what areas the Protection of Privacy Law is appropriate for a change, update or addition. In order to get as broad a point of view as possible, we are now open to the public to express a position regarding the issues that appear in the document1The Privacy Protection Law governs public data as well. This being the case, opening consultation on the law satisfies consultation for both personal and public data governance.
Japan1Japan's Protection of Personal Information Act was revised, and accepted public consultation/comments from June 2020 to July 2020. Revisions to Japan's APPI 1Public consultations held in 2017 here on the "protection of personal information held by administrative organizations"1Advisory Board on Artificial Intelligence and Human Society - This is why the Advisory Board on Artificial Intelligence and Human Society was set up in May 2016 under the initiative of the Minister of State for Science and Technology Policy with the aim to assess different societal issues that could possibly be raised by the development and deployment of AI and to discuss its implication for society. The advisory board was expressly composed of members with various backgrounds in fields such as engineering, philosophy, law, economics, and social sciences.https://public-comment.e-gov.go.jp/servlet/Public
Jordan1Although Jordan lacks a personal data protection law, there have been consultations on a draft personal data law. Jordan Public Consultations and Surveys 1The Ministry hereby announces the launch of its public consultation on the draft Data Classification & Management policy for a period of two weeks starting Tuesday, 22/10/2019, on the Ministry's website

https://www.modee.gov.jo/En/List/Public_Consultations_and_Surveys
Kenya1The Data Protection Act and Privacy Bill was passed after public consultation in 2019. The law ensures privacy as a natural right of citizens. Public Notice on Data Protection Bill https://ca.go.ke/consumers/public-consultations/
Malaysia1The Personal Data Protection Commissioner sought to gauge views from the public on the Personal Data Protection Act in February of 2020. The public could submit comments and feedback. Here is the report: Personal Data Protection Act Consultation Report1Malaysia released a Public Consultation Paper Data protection with recommendations aimed toward the federal government but does not specifically deal with public data 1Malaysian Industry-Government Group for High Technology - Its key role is building and driving partnerships in technology through a consensus building platform between the private and public sectors and providing strategic advice and alliances to shape high technology studies, capacity building through policy interventions as well as flagship programmes and strategies for the country.

It is governed by a Board of Directors, helmed through the Joint-Chairmenship of prominent private sector personalities and the Science Advisor to the Prime Minister
https://upc.mpc.gov.my/csp/sys/bi/%25cspapp.bi.index.cls?scnH=667&scnW=1366
Mexicohttp://www.ift.org.mx/industria/consultas-publicas-eng/public-consultation-about-preliminary-draft-regulatory-provisions-satellite-communication
Moroccohttps://www.cndp.ma/fr/
Netherlands1Implementation Act General Data Protection Regulation1The European Commission held public consultations regarding publically available datasets here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12111-Open-data-availability-of-public-datasets_en 1Congress Overheid 360 - Overheid 360° is the annual congress that provides in the ICT-needs of the local Dutch government

https://www.uu.nl/en/news/the-urgency-for-data-ethics-in-public-administration
1Advisory Council for Science, Technology, and Innovation - Science, technology and innovation are of great importance for the Netherlands. They are indispensable for economic growth and finding solutions to societal challenges, whether they be related to safety, the climate emergency, mobility or public health, to name but a few examples.https://www.internetconsultatie.nl/
New Zealand1The Office of the Privacy Commissioner is seeking public submissions on the proposed repeal and replacement of New Zealand’s six privacy codes of practice under section 33(3) of the Privacy Act 2020. Office of Privacy Commissioner1The consultation on New Zealand’s third National Action Plan resulted in a number of suggestions from civil society, academics and other members of the public relating to the Official Information Act. Consultations on OIA1Data Ethics Advisory Group - The Government Chief Data Steward (GCDS) convened a Data Ethics Advisory Group to help maximise the opportunities and benefits from new and emerging uses of data, while responsibly managing potential risk and harms.1Digital Advisory Group - A new advisory group is to be set up to advise the Government on how it can build the digital economy and reduce digital divides. https://www.govt.nz/browse/engaging-with-government/consultations-have-your-say/consultations-listing/
Nigeria1INVITATION TO COMMENT ON THE DRAFT DATA PROTECTION BILL, 20201The preamble of this National ICT Policy promoting open data mentions consultations with civil societyTech Advisory Council - The council which is part of the Industrial Policy and Competitiveness Advisory Council established by President Muhammadu Buhari in 2017 is to add value to governments existing policies by coming up with an inclusive and all-embracing roadmap for promoting the technology and creative sector in order to create jobs, contribute to growth and improve the well-being of Nigerians.https://ncc.gov.ng/technology/internet/internet-public-consultations
Norway1Public consultations were held for consumer protection legistlation, which involved securing personal data in transactions. Norwegian Data Protection Authority1No public consultations found related to Norway's Freedom of Information Act.

However, Norway's Second Action Plan on Open Government Partnership was released for public consultation
The National Committee for Research Ethics in the Social Sciences and the Humanities on Internet Research Ethics - This guide describes these different factors and aspects in more detail with regard to five areas: 1) The distinction between private and public; 2) The concern for children and vulnerable groups; 3) The responsibility to inform and obtain consent; 4) The responsibility for confidentiality and anonymisation; and 5) Sharing of data, open data and Big Data.https://www.regjeringen.no/en/find-document/consultations/id1763/
Pakistan1 A consultation draft of the Personal Data Protection Bill 2020 (“PDPB”) has been introduced by the Ministry of Information Technology and Telecommunications with a view to having the same being promulgated into law after public consultation, approval from both Houses of Parliament and receipt of assent from the President of Pakistan. DLA Piper: Pakistan1The Personal Data Protection Bill extends to data subjects who are natural persons. The scope of the Bill, when enacted, will apply to any person who processes, has control over, or authorises the processing of any personal data, provided any of the data subject, controller, or processor (either local or foreign) is located in Pakistan. Given that this would include the government, I would count this as a public consultation on public data governance. Pakistan Data Governancehttps://www.pta.gov.pk/en/consultation-papers
Philippines1The National Privacy Commission (NPC) will have public consultations on the draft implementing rules and regulations (IRR) of the Data Privacy Act. 1National Academy of Science and Technology - Through its advisory activities, NAST has been able to bring science and technology closer to the lives of the Filipino. Its series of information fora and roundtable discussions have encouraged public participation in open discussions of important and pressing issues in science and technology on a wide range of topics such as biotechnology, genetic engineering, intellectual property rights, information and communications technology, high performance computing, sustainable agriculture and waste management, water resource management among others. Academicians and other local and foreign experts have put their knowledge and expertise together to advise the legislators and the senate, including other policy making bodies of the government and non-government entities, on policies related to science and technology.https://www.ipophil.gov.ph/news/public-consultation-2020/
Russia1Federal Treasury launches public consultation on amendments to order of Federal Treasury on processing personal data.Council for Data Ethics - The Code of Data Ethics adopted by leading companies in December 2019 is a code of rules and regulations for data handling and management and the basis of big data market self-regulation in Russia.

The Council for Ethics includes representatives of the companies signatories of the Code: Gazprom-Media Holding, Yandex, MegaFon, Tinkoff Group, Sberbank, Gazprombank (Joint Stock Company), oneFactor, QIWI Group, Mail.ru Group, VTB Group, VimpelCom, Skolkovo Foundation, Rostelecom, MTS and representatives of the Analytical Centre at the RF Government, Big Data Association and Internet Development Institute.
Saudi Arabia1Public Consultation Document on the Proposed Regulation for Cloud Computing section 7.5 Protection of User Data
Public Consultation Document on the Cybersecurity Regulatory Framework for the ICT Sector
Regulatory Framework on Internet of Things (IoT)
https://www.citc.gov.sa/en/New/PublicConsultation/Pages/default.aspx
Singapore1There was public consultation related to an amendment to Singapore's Personal Data Protection Bill found here1PUBLIC CONSULTATION ON THE PUBLIC SECTOR (GOVERNANCE) BILL1Advisory Council on the Ethical Use of Artificial Intelligence ("AI") and Data - The Advisory Council will advise and work with the Infocomm Media Development Authority (IMDA) on the responsible development and deployment of AI. Amongst other things, the Advisory Council will assist IMDA in engaging stakeholders on issues that support the development of AI governance capabilities and frameworks. These include engaging ethics boards of commercial enterprises on ethical and related issues arising from private sector use of AI and data; consumer representatives on consumer expectations and acceptance of the use of AI; as well as members of the private capital community on the need to incorporate ethical considerations in their investment decisions into businesses which develop or adopt AI.

The Advisory Council will also assist the Government in developing ethics standards and reference governance frameworks, and publish advisory guidelines, practical guides, and codes of practice for the voluntary adoption by the industry.
https://www.reach.gov.sg/Participate/Public-Consultation
South Africa1GG 41105, GoN 709, 08 Sep 2017 - Protection of Personal Information Act, 2013 (Act. 4 of 2013): Invitation to comment on Draft Regulations relating to the Protection of Personal Information. 1On the 1st of April 2021, the Department published a draft data and cloud policy for public comments for a period of 30 days.https://www.gov.za/documents/public-comment
South Korea1Public Notice No. 2021-1 of the Personal Information Protection Committee, Personal Information Protection Act Partial Amendment (Proposed) Legislative Notice1https://www.opengovpartnership.org/documents/south-korea-end-of-term-report-2016-2018/1the Korea Communications Commission formed a public-private council that regularly collects the opinions of members of the intelligent information society, including users, companies, experts, and the international community, and continuously adheres to the principles in line with the development of intelligent information technology and the speed of service dissemination1Presidential Committee on the 4th Industrial Revolution
Sweden1The European Data Protection Board held public consultations for the GDPR ended in October of 2020. EDPB Consultations for GDPR 1The European Commission held public consultations regarding publically available datasets here: https://ec.europa.eu/info/law/better-regulation/have-your-say/initiatives/12111-Open-data-availability-of-public-datasets_en Swedish Ethical Review Authority under the Swedish National Data Service https://www.svebio.se/en/our-mission/consultations/
Switzerland1The Swiss Federal Council launched a consultation period for the Ordinance on the Data Protection Act. 1Federal Council opens consultation on the federal law on the use of electronic means to fulfill official functions
Approval and implementation of the exchange of notes between Switzerland and the EU regarding the adoption of Regulations (EU) 2021/1150 and (EU) 2021/1152 with regard to the definition of the conditions for access to other EU information systems for ETIAS purposes (further developments of Schengen - holdings)
https://fedlex.data.admin.ch/eli/dl/proj/2021/17/cons_1
https://fedlex.data.admin.ch/eli/dl/proj/2021/22/cons_1
https://fedlex.data.admin.ch/eli/dl/proj/6020/25/cons_1
https://fedlex.data.admin.ch/eli/dl/proj/6020/26/cons_1
https://fedlex.data.admin.ch/eli/dl/proj/6017/61/cons_1
The Ethical, Legal and Social Implications advisory group (ELSIag) of the Swiss Personalized Health Network (SPHN) - was mandated to produce ethical guidance in relation to personal data processing within the SPHN, with particular emphasis on guidance for data sharing.1Swiss Science Council - The Swiss Science Council (SWR) advises the Confederation on all questions relating to science, higher education, research and innovation policy.

Education, research and innovation in a digital society
Different skills in handling and using new technologies, but also unequal access to digital infrastructure can lead to a digital divide. The danger of unequal opportunities concerns education, research and innovation. The SWR helps to analyze the competencies and skills that are particularly important in a digital society.
https://www.finma.ch/en/documentation/consultations/
https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/de/consultation-procedures
https://www.fedlex.admin.ch/de/consultation-procedures?news_period=last_day&news_pageNb=1&news_order=desc&news_itemsPerPage=10
Taiwan1 The Government held several public hearings to solicit public comments on amendments to the PDPA in 2019. More information here.https://info.vtaiwan.tw/
Thailand
Turkey1Turkey: ICTA Launches A Public Consultation On The Draft ePrivacy Regulation.1https://www.dailysabah.com/life/experts-to-map-out-turkeys-strategy-on-ai-centered-on-ethics-and-data-protection/news
Ugandahttps://www.ucc.co.ug/category/publicconsultation/
Ukraine1Draft Law on Amendments to Certain Legislative Acts to Ensure Openness to the Public of Information on Financing the Activities of Public Associations and the Use of International Technical Assistancehttps://itd.rada.gov.ua/services/pubd/
United Arab Emirates1The UAE has an Open Data Portal found here. There is also a link for e-participation/e-consultation, but all data is in Arabic, and I am unsure as to if consultation pertains to open data policy. Open Data is fairly limited according to the data displayed on the portal (mainly concerns foriegn direct investment and trade). No evidence elsewhere of public consutlation.

Consultation on "The importance of publishing open data in enhancing transparency frameworks related to government work"
https://u.ae/en/participate/consultations
United Kingdom1ICO consults on how organisations can continue to protect people’s personal data when it’s transferred outside of the UK1UK held consultations on the National Data Strategy here1https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/centre-for-data-ethics-and-innovationhttps://consult.justice.gov.uk/
United States1March 9, 2021, Extension of the Public Comment Period for Proposed Modifications to the HIPAA Privacy Rule1Request for Public Comment on Draft Desirable Characteristics of Repositories for Managing and Sharing Data Resulting From Federally Funded ResearchThere is a Federal Data Ethics Framework but it seems that mostly only government officials were consulted.https://www.regulations.gov/
Uruguay1Public Consultation: General Principles on the use of artificial intelligence for digital government.1Digital Agenda Uruguay - It is a multi-stakeholder agreement between representatives of government, academia, the private sector and civil society organisations through a National Council for the Information Society.

The vehicle for achieving this agenda was the Agency for the Promotion of the Electronic Government, Information and Knowledge Society (AGESIC). Its website was created in 2006 and the agency officially began operations in July 2007. It established a number of information society objectives: equity and social inclusion; civil participation; state transformation; fostering education; innovation and knowledge generation; and domestic and international integration.
Vietnam1On February 9, 2021, the Ministry of Public Security completed the draft Decree on personal data protection to collect comments from agencies, organizations and individualshttp://chinhphu.vn/portal/page/portal/English
United Nations Expert Group on Governance of Data and AIhttps://www.oecd.org/gov/digital-government/good-practice-principles-for-data-ethics-in-the-public-sector.pdf

International
100

United Kingdom

International Performance

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 6 ScoreConvention 108+Open Government PartnershipOECD AI PrinciplesTrade agreements with binding provisions on cross-border data flows
United KingdomEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
GermanyEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
AustraliaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
NetherlandsEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
FranceEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
New ZealandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
South KoreaEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income75111
BrazilLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income5011
IrelandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1 -251
FinlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
SwedenEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
JapanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income5011
EstoniaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
CanadaNorth America1 - High income75111
SwitzerlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
NorwayEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
United StatesNorth America1 - High income75111
UruguayLatin America & Caribbean1 - High income5011
ChinaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
SingaporeEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income251
HungaryEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
IsraelMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income5011
ArgentinaLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income75111
PhilippinesEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income251
UkraineEurope & Central Asia3 - Lower middle income5011
TurkeyEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income251
MexicoLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income75111
RussiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income251
South AfricaSub-Saharan Africa2 - Upper middle income251
IndonesiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income5011
ThailandEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
KenyaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income251
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income
ChileLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income75111
JordanMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income251
MalaysiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income5011
VietnamEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income251
TaiwanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income
GeorgiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income251
IndiaSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
NigeriaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income251
MoroccoMiddle East & North Africa3 - Lower middle income251
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income
AzerbaijanEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
PakistanSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
UgandaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
BoliviaLatin America & Caribbean3 - Lower middle income
BangladeshSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
EthiopiaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
IranMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income

CountryRegionIncome categoryAttribute 6 ScoreConvention 108+Open Government PartnershipOECD AI PrinciplesTrade agreements with binding provisions on cross-border data flows
United KingdomEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
GermanyEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
AustraliaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
NetherlandsEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
FranceEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
New ZealandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
South KoreaEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income75111
BrazilLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income5011
IrelandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
European UnionEurope & Central Asia1 -251
FinlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
SwedenEurope & Central Asia1 - High income1001111
JapanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income5011
EstoniaEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
CanadaNorth America1 - High income75111
SwitzerlandEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
NorwayEurope & Central Asia1 - High income5011
United StatesNorth America1 - High income75111
UruguayLatin America & Caribbean1 - High income5011
ChinaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
SingaporeEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income251
HungaryEurope & Central Asia1 - High income75111
IsraelMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income5011
ArgentinaLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income75111
PhilippinesEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income251
UkraineEurope & Central Asia3 - Lower middle income5011
TurkeyEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income251
MexicoLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income75111
RussiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income251
South AfricaSub-Saharan Africa2 - Upper middle income251
IndonesiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income5011
ThailandEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
KenyaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income251
Saudi ArabiaMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income
ChileLatin America & Caribbean2 - Upper middle income75111
JordanMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income251
MalaysiaEast Asia & Pacific2 - Upper middle income251
Côte d’IvoireSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income5011
VietnamEast Asia & Pacific3 - Lower middle income251
TaiwanEast Asia & Pacific1 - High income
GeorgiaEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income251
IndiaSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
NigeriaSub-Saharan Africa3 - Lower middle income251
MoroccoMiddle East & North Africa3 - Lower middle income251
United Arab EmiratesMiddle East & North Africa1 - High income
AzerbaijanEurope & Central Asia2 - Upper middle income
PakistanSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
UgandaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
BoliviaLatin America & Caribbean3 - Lower middle income
BangladeshSouth Asia3 - Lower middle income
EthiopiaSub-Saharan Africa4 - Low income
IranMiddle East & North Africa2 - Upper middle income

CountryConvention 108Convention 108 sourceOpen Government PartnershipOpen Government Partnership sourceOECD AI PrinciplesOECD AI Principles sourceTrade agreements with binding provisions on cross-border data flowsTrade agreements with binding provisions on cross-border data flows source
Argentina1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Argentina Open Government Partnership1
Australia1Australia Open Government Partnership11https://rcepsec.org/2020/11/26/rcep-a-new-trade-agreement-that-will-shape-global-economics-and-politics/
Azerbaijan1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108
Bangladesh
Bolivia
Brazil1Brazil Open Government Partnership1
Canada1Canada Open Government Partnership11https://www.international.gc.ca/trade-commerce/trade-agreements-accords-commerciaux/agr-acc/index.aspx?lang=eng
Chile1Chile Open Government Partnership11https://www.subrei.gob.cl/landings/depa
China1http://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicSearchByCrResult.aspx
Côte d’Ivoire1Côte d'Ivoire Open Government Partnership1
Estonia1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Estonia Open Government Partnership1http://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicSearchByCrResult.aspx
Ethiopia
European Union1https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
Finland1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Finland Open Government Partnership11https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
France1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081France Open Government Partnership11https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
Georgia1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Georgia Open Government Partnership
Germany1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Germany Open Government Partnership11https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
Hungary1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 10811https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
India
Indonesia1Indonesia Open Government Partnership1
Iran
Ireland1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Ireland Open Government Partnership11https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
Israel1Israell Open Government Partnership1
Japan11http://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicSearchByCrResult.aspx
Jordan1Jordan Open Government Partnership
Kenya1Kenya Open Government Partnership
Malaysia1https://rcepsec.org/
Mexico1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Mexico Open Government Partnership11http://www.sice.oas.org/ctyindex/MEX/MEXagreements_e.asp
Morocco1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Morocco Open Government Partnership
Netherlands1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Netherlands Open Government Partnership11https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
New Zealand1New Zealand Open Government Partnership11https://www.mfat.govt.nz/en/trade/free-trade-agreements/free-trade-agreements-in-force/digital-economy-partnership-agreement-depa/
Nigeria1Nigeria Open Government Partnership
Norway1Norway Open Government Partnership1
Pakistan
Philippines1Philippines Open Government Partnership
Russia1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 108
Saudi Arabia
Singapore1https://www.mti.gov.sg/Improving-Trade/Digital-Economy-Agreements
South Africa1South Africa Open Government Partnership
South Korea1Republic of Korea Open Government Partnership11https://rcepsec.org/
Sweden1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Sweden Open Government Partnership11https://ec.europa.eu/trade/policy/accessing-markets/goods-and-services/digital-trade/
Switzerland1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 10811https://www.mofa.go.jp/region/europe/switzerland/epa0902/agreement.pdf
Taiwan
Thailand1https://home.kpmg/th/en/home/insights/2021/01/regional-comprehensive-economic-partnership-rcep.html
Turkey1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081
Uganda
Ukraine1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Ukraine Open Government Partnership1
United Arab Emirates
United Kingdom1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081United Kingdom Open Government Partnership11https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/the-uks-trade-agreements#trade-negotiations-the-uk-is-prioritising
United States1United States Open Government Partnership11https://ustr.gov/trade-agreements/free-trade-agreements
Uruguay1Chart of signatures and ratifications of Treaty 1081Uruguay Open Government Partnership
Vietnam1http://rtais.wto.org/UI/PublicSearchByCrResult.aspx